Page 10 of 24
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 2:49 am
by dmboogie
Zetsu wrote: ↑Sat Jun 06, 2020 12:43 am
@gianni if ur town pls hammer urself
Zetsu wrote: ↑Sat Jun 06, 2020 12:46 am
(if you dont self-vote im scumreading you next phase anyways for burning us out of a day phase, bc we'd be doing the exact same thing tomorrow, only we're down a day phase.)
im mad that i wasn't around at deadline because this is just completely awful
vote: zetsu
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 2:50 am
by dmboogie
i don't believe that town should ever self-vote and especially never self-hammer
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 2:59 am
by Fenris
ok so it could be sheer coincidence Or condor might have successfully guarded someone. i would honestly bet on the latter because condor would make a weird night 1 mafia target imo. i dont know if speculating on who he might have protected/who is an obvious day 1 target for mafia is necessarily that productive tho.
@ boogie: i see where you're coming from but i feel like zetsu has made this point in the past so it doesnt ping scummy of her @ me. i do think demanding town vote for themselves is at best a weird call tho, like for the record/re: future discourse on the matter. i think day one lynches are important for increasing available information but it isnt guaranteed that day 2 is gonna turn into a repeat of day 1 if no lynch is called for, Especially in situations like this where gianni was kind of an arbitrary target among several.
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:06 am
by Latin For Dragula
so like we're in a game where basically everyone is power roles and also it's tiny so this is gonna be resolved in like three phases right? Right. so i don't see a lot of point in holding my cards.
I'm the rogue. My role is town thief. Every night I steal from someone and Blizz will give me an item that tells me something about their flavor, which makes me feel more like a role cop unless I'm getting duped somehow? Idk, my PM also specifically calls out me having shadow magic but I'm a rogue so I'm not super sure what's up with that either but it makes me inclined to trust boogie; i literally just noticed this as i was writing this post before somebody gets wifom on our interactions, wasn't paying enough attention last phase to notice.
I stole from MW last night and got some sheet music called waltz of the myconoids that I'm too lazy to spell check. So uh, he's a bard? Is that good? Is that bad? Someone smarter and with more time than me figure it out
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:07 am
by Latin For Dragula
Way i figure it anything that gets us closer to whether we can trust MW is a win so I'm not waiting around for more results i can't do anything with
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:08 am
by Latin For Dragula
I don't buy that Zetsu is making scum moves but i buy that boogie thinks she is and am comfortable trusting him as a town voice regardless. I think she does this like, every lunch tho
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:09 am
by Latin For Dragula
And one more just because i feel like what's up you cool babies
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:17 am
by Grand Moff Hissa
Fenris wrote: ↑Tue Jun 09, 2020 2:59 am
ok so it could be sheer coincidence Or condor might have successfully guarded someone. i would honestly bet on the latter because condor would make a weird night 1 mafia target imo. i dont know if speculating on who he might have protected/who is an obvious day 1 target for mafia is necessarily that productive tho.
Especially in this case I think this is on the money because we have at 3-4 viable tactical day one shots off site rep, plus an obnoxiously townie figure in Boogie, plus maybe Condor just got lucky rolling the dice and/or was popped intentionally.
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:20 am
by Grand Moff Hissa
Emprexx Plush wrote: ↑Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:06 am
so like we're in a game where basically everyone is power roles and also it's tiny so this is gonna be resolved in like three phases right? Right. so i don't see a lot of point in holding my cards.
I'm the rogue. My role is town thief. Every night I steal from someone and Blizz will give me an item that tells me something about their flavor, which makes me feel more like a role cop unless I'm getting duped somehow? Idk, my PM also specifically calls out me having shadow magic but I'm a rogue so I'm not super sure what's up with that either but it makes me inclined to trust boogie; i literally just noticed this as i was writing this post before somebody gets wifom on our interactions, wasn't paying enough attention last phase to notice.
I stole from MW last night and got some sheet music called waltz of the myconoids that I'm too lazy to spell check. So uh, he's a bard? Is that good? Is that bad? Someone smarter and with more time than me figure it out
Okay, there's a chance this is a scum claim getting ahead of the heat/some shadiness going on but the role itself is good stuff and I'm inclined to townread. I am indeed the bard, I can more or less prove it if push comes to shove, and my power is a quirky thing that, comboed with our flips on Goose and Condor, all line up really nicely with Paige's claim to make it seem legit.
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:42 am
by dmboogie
MurderWeasel wrote: ↑Tue Jun 09, 2020 3:17 am
plus an obnoxiously townie figure in Boogie
i think this is the first time in my life ive been called that
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 4:47 am
by Zetsu
I received a PM saying I heard music playing outside my window, so I'm pretty well inclined to think that MW's telling the truth about being a bard. That makes me inclined to trust that Paige is telling the truth about their role, too.
Deamon's been posting but his posts contain a whole lot of nothing.
Still waiting on this, Ricky.
MK Kilmarnock wrote:Ricky's...quiet. Too quiet. It makes me uneasy. Then again, I feel like everyone here is being unusually quiet on account of *gestures around vaguely at everything* but also being unusually quiet coincided with him being scum last game. Not a scumtell by any means, just enough to make me raise my eyebrows and ask for explanation.
Agree that Condor probably died protecting someone.
@Paige Since you're going ahead and laying out all the cards on the table: what effect does having shadow magic flavor do to you, mechanically speaking? Are you also a miller?
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 4:57 am
by Fenris
if we're playing cards on the table i can also indirectly confirm that paige is telling the truth though not necessarily their alignment i guess
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 4:58 am
by Grand Moff Hissa
Zetsu wrote: ↑Tue Jun 09, 2020 4:47 am
I received a PM saying I heard music playing outside my window, so I'm pretty well inclined to think that MW's telling the truth about being a bard. That makes me inclined to trust that Paige is telling the truth about their role, too
^Yep, there we go. Points for being unprompted, though of course limited points given I was gonna be calling a witness fairly obviously anyways if need be and there are only so many mysterious dashing serenaders.
Also I have nothing about shadow magic in my PM, in case that's in any way relevant.
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 4:58 am
by Zetsu
@Murder: my impression, then, is that you're basically a fruit vendor?
I think we can pretty safely assume that, in a game this size, there's only one kill available. 2 or 3 scum both seem possible to me. Someone else do the setup speculation though pls, my last couple attempts at that have been disastrous.
Re: D&D Mafia Game Thread
Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2020 5:03 am
by Zetsu
@random whomst are your scumreads?
@decoy say something, anything