Re: De-Evolving
Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 6:59 am
Luke laughed at Teo's response, but paused at Bounce and Charles's reaction.
"Not a stunt?" Luke though, thinking about the implications for a second before shaking them off. "No, it can't be real, there are too many flaws in the possibility.
Luke mused on the ideas. What would a person have to gain for doing a show like that, if it were real? Money, perhaps? Getting a show on air takes quite a bit of money and manpower, not to mention costs for equiptment like cameras, and recording, and all the infostructure to produce a show. It can't be through merchandise and television, surely? Those have papertrails and links that anyone should be able to trace back to their source.
Logistics were another thing. Transporting a mass of people, suddenly dissapearing from their lives? Improbable, near impossible. Not really something imaginably *quiet.* And what of the winner? If the show was true, then surely their experiences would be heard, more wideplace? The governement would know whether all of this were true or not and thus there would be measures within our school system to prevent this sort of thing occuring to student here. The government cracked down on terrorism after 9/11, securing the airlines and leading a war. Isn't this show, if real, no different?
No, it can't be real. Luke summerised, Besides, the idea that someone would willing have students, people whom they were friends with, willingly end those bonds is.... just too terrifing. It has to be fake.
Luke looked up at Bounce. Though, whoever this girl is, she appears to know a bit about it. Luke paused, then grinned to himself, smelling a challenge, Let's see if it stands up to reason.
Luke heard Teo talking, but he didn't notice: his interest had been piqued.
"I still believe the show to be a stunt and I'll prove it." Luke said to Bounce and Charles, pulling out his notebook and ripping out some pages. He arranged them in a brainstorm-style, placing "SOTF, stunt or not?" in the middle, with blank pages around it. He wrote, "Money" "Government" and "Operation" on a seperate page each.
"Take this point," Luke indicated, picking up the page saying "Money" and moving it to the centre of the table. "A show like this, real or fake, would require a heck of a lot of it to run. Besides however they film the thing and what all that equiptment costs, there is whatever the students get; various weapons, whatever. Costs after these basic needs for it to run would diverge here, depending if it were real or not. If fake, there's only the cost of props and actor salaries, within a studios budget."
"But, if real, then costs rise a significant amount." Luke continued, adjusting his glasses while he was speaking, "We would then be talking real weapons, the cost of getting real people there, keeping the people there in terms of manpower and physical security, like an electric fence as an example to keep them all in place. Then, after said show is said and done, getting it to a station to be broadcasted, which, geez, is another bag of worms. Quickly, I can't imagine studios would willingly accept being handed the show if it were real and if they were, that sort of thing must be traceable. So, if real, they're putting themselves on side of terrorism. Maybe they would, it wouldn't surprise me but I honestly would doubt it. Therefore, if we keep to the line of thought that it is real in this senario, it must be hacked into the station it is broadcasted on. Which, once again, is more money. I guess if one has the ability to hack a station, theyhave theability to stop it being traced so easily, but still."
"Forgive me for thinking it out for so long, but my point is this," Luke finalised, leaning back on his chair. "IF real, this show would cost a staggering amount in pure production and the more money it costs the easier it would be to find it and shut it down. I just can't see it being feasible. How do they gather the funding to keep it going? It can't be something so obvious as mercandise. Why? Paper trails are traceable, they wouldnt produce it themselves as companies aren't the easiest things to hide and if real, it's the first place someone looking to shut it down would go."
Luke looked to the table, interested in hearing thoughts on the matter. He was wishing he knew a little more about the subject matter; some of his thoughts probably were addressed long ago. Then again, his mind wandering back to the implications of what it meant if it were real, he was glad he knew so little.
"Not a stunt?" Luke though, thinking about the implications for a second before shaking them off. "No, it can't be real, there are too many flaws in the possibility.
Luke mused on the ideas. What would a person have to gain for doing a show like that, if it were real? Money, perhaps? Getting a show on air takes quite a bit of money and manpower, not to mention costs for equiptment like cameras, and recording, and all the infostructure to produce a show. It can't be through merchandise and television, surely? Those have papertrails and links that anyone should be able to trace back to their source.
Logistics were another thing. Transporting a mass of people, suddenly dissapearing from their lives? Improbable, near impossible. Not really something imaginably *quiet.* And what of the winner? If the show was true, then surely their experiences would be heard, more wideplace? The governement would know whether all of this were true or not and thus there would be measures within our school system to prevent this sort of thing occuring to student here. The government cracked down on terrorism after 9/11, securing the airlines and leading a war. Isn't this show, if real, no different?
No, it can't be real. Luke summerised, Besides, the idea that someone would willing have students, people whom they were friends with, willingly end those bonds is.... just too terrifing. It has to be fake.
Luke looked up at Bounce. Though, whoever this girl is, she appears to know a bit about it. Luke paused, then grinned to himself, smelling a challenge, Let's see if it stands up to reason.
Luke heard Teo talking, but he didn't notice: his interest had been piqued.
"I still believe the show to be a stunt and I'll prove it." Luke said to Bounce and Charles, pulling out his notebook and ripping out some pages. He arranged them in a brainstorm-style, placing "SOTF, stunt or not?" in the middle, with blank pages around it. He wrote, "Money" "Government" and "Operation" on a seperate page each.
"Take this point," Luke indicated, picking up the page saying "Money" and moving it to the centre of the table. "A show like this, real or fake, would require a heck of a lot of it to run. Besides however they film the thing and what all that equiptment costs, there is whatever the students get; various weapons, whatever. Costs after these basic needs for it to run would diverge here, depending if it were real or not. If fake, there's only the cost of props and actor salaries, within a studios budget."
"But, if real, then costs rise a significant amount." Luke continued, adjusting his glasses while he was speaking, "We would then be talking real weapons, the cost of getting real people there, keeping the people there in terms of manpower and physical security, like an electric fence as an example to keep them all in place. Then, after said show is said and done, getting it to a station to be broadcasted, which, geez, is another bag of worms. Quickly, I can't imagine studios would willingly accept being handed the show if it were real and if they were, that sort of thing must be traceable. So, if real, they're putting themselves on side of terrorism. Maybe they would, it wouldn't surprise me but I honestly would doubt it. Therefore, if we keep to the line of thought that it is real in this senario, it must be hacked into the station it is broadcasted on. Which, once again, is more money. I guess if one has the ability to hack a station, theyhave theability to stop it being traced so easily, but still."
"Forgive me for thinking it out for so long, but my point is this," Luke finalised, leaning back on his chair. "IF real, this show would cost a staggering amount in pure production and the more money it costs the easier it would be to find it and shut it down. I just can't see it being feasible. How do they gather the funding to keep it going? It can't be something so obvious as mercandise. Why? Paper trails are traceable, they wouldnt produce it themselves as companies aren't the easiest things to hide and if real, it's the first place someone looking to shut it down would go."
Luke looked to the table, interested in hearing thoughts on the matter. He was wishing he knew a little more about the subject matter; some of his thoughts probably were addressed long ago. Then again, his mind wandering back to the implications of what it meant if it were real, he was glad he knew so little.