Re: High Tide Rising
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 9:18 am
Roxanne nodded. “I see.”
She hadn’t asked the question to judge the quality of Marcy’s answer - though she did think it a little naive. It was like a trolley problem. It didn’t really matter what the final answer was. The point of the exercise was to force you to closely examine your own morality, where your priorities lay.
What if Marcy killed said protective killer in self-defense, and was forced to kill their formerly-innocent, now-enraged companion as well? Was a second charge of self-defense a sufficient balm for that guilt, the knowledge that her crusade now had civilian casualties? Would she justify it with guilt-by-association? Did being angered to the point of violence by a murderer’s death make one equally deserving of death?
You could spiral forever, obsessing over permutations of hypothetical scenarios like that one. So far away from civilization, morality was at its most subjective. Did that make it matter less? Or more? Did the freedom mean a release from standards, allowed at last to follow your whims and gut instincts to decide what actions you could live with, not giving a damn about consistency? Or did it make it even more important to cast yourself in iron? To see everything your small world had to offer, the depths you could fall to, and still commit yourself to a single way of life?
There she was, spiraling again.
“Good to think about things like that beforehand,” Roxanne said, habitually hiding her intentions. No need for Marcy to catch on that she was being tested. That would just unnecessarily complicate their dynamic. “Won’t have much time to think about it in the thick of things.”
She hadn’t asked the question to judge the quality of Marcy’s answer - though she did think it a little naive. It was like a trolley problem. It didn’t really matter what the final answer was. The point of the exercise was to force you to closely examine your own morality, where your priorities lay.
What if Marcy killed said protective killer in self-defense, and was forced to kill their formerly-innocent, now-enraged companion as well? Was a second charge of self-defense a sufficient balm for that guilt, the knowledge that her crusade now had civilian casualties? Would she justify it with guilt-by-association? Did being angered to the point of violence by a murderer’s death make one equally deserving of death?
You could spiral forever, obsessing over permutations of hypothetical scenarios like that one. So far away from civilization, morality was at its most subjective. Did that make it matter less? Or more? Did the freedom mean a release from standards, allowed at last to follow your whims and gut instincts to decide what actions you could live with, not giving a damn about consistency? Or did it make it even more important to cast yourself in iron? To see everything your small world had to offer, the depths you could fall to, and still commit yourself to a single way of life?
There she was, spiraling again.
“Good to think about things like that beforehand,” Roxanne said, habitually hiding her intentions. No need for Marcy to catch on that she was being tested. That would just unnecessarily complicate their dynamic. “Won’t have much time to think about it in the thick of things.”