Colour drained from Regina’s skin, as if the rain was washing it away too. Her strength ebbed, hands falling from Caroline’s grasp limply, slick with blood and water. Looking into her glassy eyes, it was easy to imagine the darkness on the other side of the tiny, convex panes.
Before long even Regina’s warm smile was as cold and dead as everything else.
Caroline reached up and helped Regina close her eyes for the last time. She slumped down against the tree next to her. Sniffling. Shaking. Eyes scanning the woods nearby, as if the person who did this would leap out at any moment.
No, not from the woods,
that girl was right here,
sitting right next to the person they’d destroyed,
broken apart by the broken parts of her mind,
deprived of even being able to atone for it
because she was well past making her own choices,
aren’t i?
Something that sounded like a person shearing apart broke through the white noise of rain on thick brush. The agonized scream that clawed its way from Caroline’s throat seemed to drag along with it everything she’d had left to feel. The love she felt for Regina, the compassion she felt for everyone else trapped here, and even the hate and confusion she felt for the terrorists. All expelled into the humid air, condensing and running into the dirt with everything else.
Eventually the pain in her throat and the empty space in her chest silenced her. Caroline drew her knees up against her chest, staring ahead at the twisted grey world through the water droplets on her glasses. Unsure whether she was staring up from the bottom of a pit, or down into one.
As she crossed the event horizon she found herself greeted by a host of dozens of leering silhouettes cast against the backdrop of the seemingly endless, lush forest. They differed in motive. Some watched with curiosity, or excitement. Others watched with sympathy, and more still with hatred.
Yet all of them watched.
They waited. Wondering what was next for her. For them.
Please, let me explain.
It kept her going at first, the idea that so long as she understood what was real and what wasn’t, there was hope. Reality, while unforgiving, responded to attempts to change it. All that she’d experienced told her that nothing on the island could be even remotely as horrible as what her own mind could conjure up. If she’d had her medication, that could’ve been a source of strength. Instead, she’d managed to lose that method of control within hours. No peer-turned-monster could be so pernicious or persistent as her own demons. There was no running away from oneself. No way to fight back in a place like this, not in any appreciable way that meant anything.
In her few moments of clarity on that first day, feeling the chemicals dissolve in her hands as she tried to claw the pills back from the lake, she understood what it all meant. Regardless of whether anyone else visited mercy upon her, she would always be at the mercy of her broken mind. Losing a friend was hard enough. Knowing she killed her even more difficult to comprehend or accept. It was painfully clear that she was hours away to watching whatever dignity and agency she had left melt through her fingers.
If it wasn’t the staggering numbness she felt, it was the way that everything seemed to fade and collapse together. Trees only seemed to be shapes she knew were supposed to be plants. It was difficult to see how the collection of steel and wood lying next to her was meant to be a weapon. In this light, words failed to describe what much of anything was. Even her hands didn’t seem like they belonged on the ends of her extremities. Just like the lead hail she saw pelting the ground outside didn’t seem to belong there either.
Caroline snuck a glance to her left, and at least saw what she expected to see.
“I never could’ve made up someone like you.”
Genuine kindness like Regina’s was no mistake. It had been a gift. Definitely not something she would have just hallucinated. No, she was special. For a time Caroline even thought that maybe her presence alone would see her through this. That she was now lying dead at Caroline’s side was proof enough to the contrary.
As she drifted away, she pondered what Regina had asked of her back on the island. It was no promise anyone could keep here honestly, if by life she’d meant getting out of here. It was hard to imagine that a person who sincerely made an effort to win this game would’ve been anything resembling sane by the end. Still, she supposed at least some baseline understanding of where vile imaginings ended and reality began was likely a prerequisite for survival.
Given that she found herself no longer sitting next to Regina, but instead at the juncture between a deep well and the open expanse of sky, she supposed it wasn’t meant to be that she survived.
How she’d wished that she understood her folly earlier on.
They encircled the well. Impatient. Some moved to shove her down, but were held back by the others. The din she’d come to expect from them all was conspicuously absent; it had faded with all of the colour in the world, the pain in her shoulder from the shotgun, and Regina’s life.
Caroline idly tossed a stone down the well, listening for the echoes as it bounced off the smooth stone walls. The darkness seemed to ripple as the pit fell silent. She glanced up towards the rainy sky, back towards the pit, and then to the figures surrounding her; engaging with it all in the way she’d been told so many times not to.
I made a mistake. I looked for truth in this place, but there wasn’t any. There was nothing real to hang onto here. The island, this forest, this moment – it’s all someone’s twisted invention. Malice made manifest. Holding on tightly only made it all slip away even faster. We stopped being real the moment they gave us numbers and dropped us into their story. All we can be here are half-empty fabrications, made from the parts of real people.
She offered a pleading glance to the crowd.
The parts they made me from must've been a bit defective. They're too broken to take any more, and too shattered to break any further.
So now what?
I want to climb back up there, to stand up and walk away. Leave her to rest. I made a promise, though. Not to leave her here. To live. What can that even mean in a place like this? Just wander the island, whittling my sanity down to a nub with each new horror?
A couple of nods. Some exchanges of excited glances. Others shuffled impatiently. Caroline shook her head.
I have faith in promises. Eternal life was made as one to me, by my Creator. I’ve lived in reverence of it my entire life, as best as I could. Despite what he made me to be, despite the role I was given to play.
I was afraid I wouldn’t be able to save myself if I didn’t know what I was saving myself from. I searched for some truth in all of this, in fear of being at the mercy of all of your falsehoods. I made a mistake thinking I could find it, and in thinking I needed to look for any truth other than the highest one.
I only need a moment to keep my promise to live. In spite of you, in spite of myself, I will.
Caroline stepped from the well, and past the crowd back towards the island.
Sitting under the tree next to Regina’s body, Caroline had been holding herself and staring out at the wilderness for some time, completely motionless. A casual observer might’ve supposed that the two of them both lay dead underneath the branches, Caroline having falling victim to some far less obvious calamity than Regina.
Life and colour returned to the world in an instant, as Caroline found herself suddenly awash with energy and focus. She stretched the tingling sensation from her arms and legs, and wiped the water and blood from her face. A fleeting lucidity moved her to action.
She couldn’t keep her promise in the way Regina intended her to. With what little time was left to make such a choice, Caroline knew she was going to do it on her own terms. For all she resented her Creator for what she’d suffered through, she knew He had given her the strength to dictate her own path through this world, and out of it. For the strength she felt in this moment, she knew she would be eternally grateful.
The silver ring on her finger seemed to gleam amidst the grey, washed out world. The etched lettering read clearly:
Choose the Right. Before it had just been a reminder of the standards she held herself to, a lodestone that would always point her to a righteous path. Maybe no one would understand what she was about to do, or what it meant. Surely some would laugh, or call her foolish and suicidal. Others might see it as a desperate sign of resistance.
Either way, she understood what it meant to her. Light shone in the darkness whether the darkness comprehended it or not. Caroline stood locking eyes with the mechanical aperture that had been watching this scene unfold. She spoke directly to it with renewed confidence and grace.
“I think I’ve had enough of this.”
She cocked the hammer on her weapon and pressed the stock against her bruised shoulder. The tiny white dot at the end of the barrel pointed squarely at the electronic eye peering down at her - the lone camera in the area which had captured Regina’s demise.
Beads of water fell from the tree above onto her glasses, threatening to throw off her aim. Caroline inhaled, and steadied herself. For the last time, she squeezed the trigger and felt the staggering recoil of the shotgun kick into her shoulder.
A gout of fire flashed before her eyes and she watched in satisfaction as a shower of sparks, glass, and twisted metal scattered across the woods nearby. A demonic hiss escaped from within the wreckage of the camera as a jet of flame and blue smoke erupted from its ruptured battery pack.
Content, Caroline threw the shotgun to the ground next to her duffel bag. As she sat back down next to Regina and the ringing in her ears abated, she could hear the steady beep coming from the collar on her neck.
Far from frightening her, she felt reassurance in the certainty of what was to come.
Caroline closed her eyes, taking Regina's hand as she met her creator in peace.
G048 – Ford, Caroline: DECEASED