Puella Magi Mafia Game Thread

[Cactus]

So we have *two* mafias and a serial killer?

[Grim Wolf]

Somewhere between 1-2 mafias, and no mafia has fewer than 2 members, is my read of it. I didn't consult the OP when developing my thoughts, but it would still fit the pattern.

[blastinus]

There MIGHT be two separate Mafia cells not in contact with one another or there might just be one big cell. It’s ambiguous enough that you could take it either way.

[Latin For Dragula]

Yeah, there can be up to two mafia of no less than two each, and no more than one serial killer. If i was gonna bet i would say either 4 mafia or 3 maf one SK, with fringe possibility in 2/2 mafs. 2/2 mafs and an SK or 4 mafs and an SK feels imbalanced

[BlizzardeyeWonder]

Well, two mafias I don't think is out of the question. While the fluff states that (likely) there are magical girls killing other magical girls, there's a chance there are still witches in this game. Honestly, there might be one (1) singular witch and that guy's the serial killer.

...oh fuck walpurgis?!

[BlizzardeyeWonder]

(I doubt walpurgisnacht is in this game in seriousness though, seems a bit powerful to be a role here to me)

[General Goose]

UNVOTE: RIKI[(/b]

VOTE: METHODICALSLACKER[(/b]

I find the turn on boogie for what are essentially joke votes rather suspect, and the attempt to portray opponents as being opposed to a day 1 lynch as a bit of a strawman argument. We need to lynch someone, true, but the boogie lynch strikes me as currently very arbitrary, and we are not at the point where we need an arbitrary lynch.

[General Goose]

Fucking formatting chucklefuck

[Cactus]

far be it for me to suggest since i know like, fuck all about mafia but aren't there jester roles that like try and get themselves lynched?

could that be behind ms' weird posting and obnoxiousness?

[Cactus]

derp, read the first post, never mind

[dmboogie]

im genuinely sure MeS is just having a larf

[Riki]

I still feel like the suspicion on MS is reaching more than Leo di Caprio did for an oscar till 2015.

Like, what exactly beyond "well he's typing weirdly" is the issue here? The idea of a jester is right out (tbh i found the discussion about possible bastard-esque situations odd? fenris is obvs going for a clean and good game so this just feels icky) anyway.

[Riki]

also just saying but this board's function to preview new posts if any have been made in the meantime you're writing a reply is %100 my jam

[MethodicalSlacker]

i don't mean to imply that people that don't want a day one lynch are bad, i'm just saying the notion that the first day is largely a crapshoot is!!!!!!!!!!! entire games can be decided on the first day!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the only thing that pushed me towards boogie is that he had more lynch votes than anyone else, and now it seems that i have the most lynch votes. this isnt a situation that can be helped. you dont lose much by losing me, but you dont gain anything either, because i dont have a role!!! am i the worst mafia player alive?! possibly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Deamon]

I would say your issue is that if someone were seriously analyzing posts that vote would always look suspect.

(For disclaimer purposes I also belive MS was messing around)