Puella Magi Mafia Game Thread

[dmboogie]

yeah, sure. if we had any power roles with actual leads left, i'm sure they woulda spoken up by now.

i'm Melissa de Vignolles, the 1x Bulletproof. i have no other special properties, so i've essentially been a vanilla townie since i got hit all those nights ago.

[dmboogie]

j

[KamiKaze]

Okay, so since Boogie claimed, I'll go.

I'm Iroha Tamaki, a character from Magia Record. I've never played it, but apparently I'm the main character? And I'm like, looking for my missing loved one like a Silent Hill character? And my wish saved her life beforehand?



Anyways, I'm nothing exciting. Vanilla townie.

[Riki]

I am Momoko Togame, who is like, totally relatable and also a Vanilla Townie

[Cactus]

In what is basically the story of my life, I share a name with an SOTF winner (Riz) and am forever coming and going.

I'm Riz Hawkwood and I'm a 3x shot Commuter.

[Cactus]

I should also mention that both of you claiming vanilla is suuuuuuper suspicious to me because we're still missing a few key town roles and that sorta reads as odd to me. Maybe it's a flavour thing but if that's the case I'm at a disadvantage. Meth slack, whatchu got?

[Riki]

I'll be honest with you, the moment Kami claimed Vanilla I actually got a strong scumread, but I was at work and couldn't really post that well between citizens going into my office. I mean, aside from the obvious mismatch of roles that are claimed to roles that should still exist, I found the effort Kami put in her claim post quite a bit too much. And it ringed my alarm bells enough I'd vote for her if not for the close voting requirement at hand.

The following claims exist:


MethodicalSlacker VANILLA TOWNIE ("because i dont have a role" were the words used, so no guarantee they actually meaned it?)
dmboogie 1X BULLETPROOF
Cactus 3X COMMUTER
KamiKaze VANILLA TOWNIE
Riki VANILLA TOWNIE

[Cactus]

Okay wait so three of you are claiming VT and boogie is basically a VT after his bulletproofing is up, which he said it already was...

That's not kosher, friends.

I don't really know how to scum read or not but that's hella sus if you ask me. Which like, great. Boils my suspect list down to everyone but me. Which I already knew.

Boogie makes me go "hmmmmm" on the random bulletproofing... It seems odd. So I'd bet there's another power there or maybe scum?

Kami - agree on the claim being like YES THIS IS ME ABSOLUTELY NO POSSIBLE SCUM HERE but it could just be overzealousness. Again, I'm bad at mafia do I don't know wtf.

At one point MS almost got lynched but iirc we figured he was fine? I... I don't know honestly. That's weird. Be nice to get some more from him.

Riki... I dunno mate. Hard to say there. But also you just claimed vt without a role name or did you say that and I. Just half asleep?

Look, content from me. It's time for a coffee. Yikes.

[Cactus]

EBWOP: Yep, I missed it, my bad Riki

[Riki]

it's okay we still love you

[dmboogie]

hm, cactus's claim is specific enough that it's hard to believe scum would try to fake it? it's def not ironclad and could just be a good gambit on his part, but it's enough to make me want to start by cutting out one of our "vanilla townies." need to reread to figure out if any of them actually, like, soar above the others in terms of suspicion

would be nice to hear from MeS

[KamiKaze]

Okay, back from work. It was a long shift.

Not gonna lie, buuuuuuuuuut... I actually agree. One or two VT claims? Sure. But THREE?!

Yeah, we need to take out one of the VTs, absolutely. Yes, I know I claimed such too.

[MethodicalSlacker]

I claimed VT a while ago. I'm Felicia Mitsuki, a Vanilla Townie. It's incredibly suspicious that we have so many Vanilla Townie claims going on right now, because as we know, that's a super safe-claim for mafia. I don't know what else to get from me other than reads. My reads are thus:

Cactus: The only one with an actually specific claim. But at the same time I'm still not totally convinced. I don't think Town has any time to verify anything anymore, nor does Town probably have any verification roles left since Toben and Paige got taken out—IIRC they both had roles that would be useful for that purpose and I don't see us having any more. This then could be a smokescreen—it looks like a reasonable claim but because we have no way of actually figuring out whether or not it's true, it's still suspicious. However, the role that was claimed itself assuages a bit of my fears. I just want to raise the possibility that this claim isn't legitimate because I'm wary of too much focused attention on all the VT claims, WHICH ARE STILL IMPORTANT, and I'm doing the wishy washy thing again fuck I haven't changed two mafias later ANYWAY.

Kami: Super town. Good play all game. Vanilla Townie I can believe, because Kami's play this entire time has been focused mainly on gaining information out in the open and rationalizing the trains that have been started which to me reads like Kami doesn't have outside role-based information.

Riki and Boogie: I've felt suspicious of both of these people at different times. Boogie's been claiming bulletproof for a while, and right now that's effectively townie, but I still don't understand why Boogie wasn't shot at again. Riki's vanilla town claim is the least satisfying of everyone here. Riki's logic for Kami claiming Vanilla as a scumread seems forced. "Too much effort" in the post because she linked, what, an image? I don't buy it. It's a little forced but not in a way that is OOC for Kami for me, and it doesn't discount the town effort that Kami's been putting in the whole game, for me. Unless Kami is SK which from what I understand means that Kami wouldn't know who Mafia is? Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

Do something with this information, sorry I haven't been very active last few days I've been sort of busy, I'll come back later tonight and lay down a vote if it's still possible to.

[Cactus]

This reminds me of the Thing, except I'm Kurt Russell and the rest of you are possibly things.

Get on the couch.

*equips flamethrower*

[Fenris]

Unless Kami is SK which from what I understand means that Kami wouldn't know who Mafia is? Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

This one falls under my purview.

Any and all third-party roles would not know the identity of any mafia members, under the Normal ruleset, which we are using.