D&D Mafia Game Thread

[Zetsu]

i mean, he's my strongest scumread? i'm not following you here. is that not ample reason to push him?

[Zetsu]

ricky, thoughts on fenris?

[Grand Moff Hissa]

I have some Deamon musings but I'm gonna hold 'em until I get a reply from him. Posting so I remember/get reminded.

[MK Kilmarnock]

My thoughts on Fenris start and end at the weirdness that was asking for everybody's classes on a day 1 mass flavorclaim which is almost never a good idea and only slightly less horrible than looking for a day 1 massclaim so... yeah, I'm side-eyeing the fuck out of that, but the reasons you gave were also suspicious (like I indicated back then).

That said I think it might be prudent to poke at Fenris first, then depending on how they flip, decide whether or not to go after you (town Fenris increases the likelihood I would gun for you next). But before I vote, can we get a votecount please, DM person?

[Deamon]

And, while we're at it, Deamon, how do you feel about Ricky?

meh

Is that "meh" you don't like his play or "meh" you don't like the question?

yes

[Grand Moff Hissa]

meh

Is that "meh" you don't like his play or "meh" you don't like the question?

yes

What do you not you like about each of these things, individually?

[BlizzardeyeWonder]

Zetsu: 2 (Boogie, Paige)
Deamon: 1 (Zetsu)

10 alive means 6 to lynch. Countdown.

[randomness]

My thoughts on Fen: My main concerns were the joke vote on the miller claim plus the mass-claim idea, both of which I initially read as testing the waters. I also don't like that the couple instances where they seemed to be giving soft outs or were explaining other people's actions before they had responded.

Re: Zetsu: I guess my main question now is if you were fishing for reactions, why you didn't prod at the responses more than you did? While knowing that half the argument was missing explains this a little, it doesn't quite allay the concern entirely since you immediately respond to the blowback by just taking an out and noting that it was a weak read.

[Zetsu]

I am prodding at the responses that interest me! Yours and ricky’s.

[MK Kilmarnock]

Votecount's good enough for me.

Vote: Fenris

[Fenris]

wow rude

for reasons vaguely hinted at repeatedly i dont have the energy to defend myself super hard unless all you want is a claim i guess. that said im also not super useful this game because i dont have the spoons to do any analysis so if yall wanna drop me as dead weight i cant really blame you?

[Fenris]

im at work at the mo but i can attempt some form of readlist tonight

[Latin For Dragula]

Votecount's good enough for me.

Vote: Fenris

can you elaborate for the rest of the class why voting for someone who like most of the game is neither voting or being voted for is explained by the vote count

[Zetsu]

This disappeared awhile back, but I'm not super against having a massclaim right now. If there's 3 scum, the next day phase is gonna be LyLo (or maybe MyLo? i cant be bothered to math rn) anyways, and I do feel that pushing it up a day to deny scum the chance to coordinate could be helpful.

Before we do that, though, I'm thinking about asking for a general show of hands on who has shadow magic in their role pm. It reveals little that scum can use, and helps the pig cop know who not to target. Scum can pretend to be townies with shadow magic in their pm's, obviously, but they'd face increased scrutiny if they do so.

[Grand Moff Hissa]

I'm down for this as well—as I see it, we've already drawn a pretty darn good circle for who scum should shoot, so evening the odds is wise.